Which test kit?

[iwannapool]

The Taylor K-2006 has the same functionality as Ben's kit. Most of the tests are identical (except for the pH, which is just as good and the acid and base demands that Ben's kit doesn't have. IMHO, for good reason!) If you want to add the OTO total chlorine test and the same pH test as Ben's kit than you also need a Taylor K-1000. The OTO test is good for quick daily checks on your clorine level. If you need the salt option then Taylor has 2 kits that will fit the bill K-1766 and K-1771. Either one is funtionally equivalent to Ben's. As an alternative you could use the AquaChek White salt test strips. This is one of the test strips that actually works. It uses the same chemistry as the Taylor kit and I have found it to be reliable. I have checked it against the Taylor kit and against both a Goldline and a LaMotte salt meter many times and the strips were always right on the money.

I took a quick look on Taylor's website and didn't see what the real difference is between the K-2006 and K-2005 test kits except that the K-2006 kit is more expensive. What did I miss?

[CarlD]

I took a quick look on Taylor's website and didn't see what the real difference is between the K-2006 and K-2005 test kits except that the K-2006 kit is more expensive. What did I miss?

K-2005 is a DPD test kit. K-2006 is a FAS-DPD test kit.
BIGGGG difference!
DPD you can only test to 15ppm on your chlorine.
FAS-DPD you can test to 50ppm or even 100ppm.

We recommend the K-2006 or K-2006C (more reagents).

However, the Leslie's FAS-DPD Service Test Kit is similar and you can get it instead. It's simply Taylor re-agents in a Leslie's box.

[iwannapool]

How often would I see CL, CC or FC, above 15 ppm? I guess if you get a big problem CC could go high, but FC? By the way, what is FAS-DPD; is it an acronym or ?

[CarlD]

How often would I see CL, CC or FC, above 15 ppm? I guess if you get a big problem CC could go high, but FC?

If CC is over 15ppm you have a problem. But FC as high as 25? Sure.

If your stabilizer level (CYA) is over 100, you have to shock by getting FC up to 25ppm. You maintain your pool at something like 12-15ppm (I've forgotten exactly).

Unless you have very low CYA (20 or less) you normally will shock to 15ppm of FC--that's now at the limit of standard DPD kits. Past 15ppm ordinary DPD can bleach out and look like 0 ppm! Use FAS-DPD and you have lots of headroom.

[DavidD]

Here's another reason why:

A friend told me they kept having problems with bleaching of bathing suits and extremely dry skin but with very little chlorine in the pool towards the end of last season. A new bathing suit started to fade in less than a week. They were using a 3" puck feeder and would load it up but keep the dial turned down. He used the DPD test (not FAS-DPD) and wasn't registering any or very little chlorine when he did the test so he kept the feeder turned down to a low setting rather than turn it off or empty it. He knew he needed chlorine and theorized it was "burning off as fast as he could put it in". I brought my (Ben's PS233) test kit over and found he was actually over 30 ppm FC among other issues! All due to an old and in inadequate test kit.
Needless to say, he is using a better test kit (a bootleg clone of mine) and now even the BBB method....



Dave

[CarlD]

Here's another reason why:

A friend told me they kept having problems with bleaching of bathing suits and extremely dry skin but with very little chlorine in the pool towards the end of last season. A new bathing suit started to fade in less than a week. They were using a 3" puck feeder and would load it up but keep the dial turned down. He used the DPD test (not FAS-DPD) and wasn't registering any or very little chlorine when he did the test so he kept the feeder turned down to a low setting rather than turn it off or empty it. He knew he needed chlorine and theorized it was "burning off as fast as he could put it in". I brought my (Ben's PS233) test kit over and found he was actually over 30 ppm FC among other issues! All due to an old and in inadequate test kit.
Needless to say, he is using a better test kit (a bootleg clone of mine) and now even the BBB method....



Dave

I'll bet his CYA level was through the roof as well! I sure hope it wasn't a vinyl pool or that'd bleach too!

Saving money on test kits is a false economy. A FAS-DPD test kit will pay for itself hundreds of times over.

[DavidD]

I'll bet his CYA level was through the roof as well! I sure hope it wasn't a vinyl pool or that'd bleach too!

Unfortunately, they had just replaced the liner in the spring. Fortunately, it doesn't appear to have been adversely affected that "we can tell". And yes, his CYA was 100+ and pH read 6.8 but was obviously less. If I remember correctly, we dumped in 4 boxes of Borax


Dave

[waterbear]

How often would I see CL, CC or FC, above 15 ppm? I guess if you get a big problem CC could go high, but FC? By the way, what is FAS-DPD; is it an acronym or ?

DPD and FAS-DPD are the reagents used.
DPD is N,N-diethyl-paraphenylenediamine. It is the indicator used to test for clorine (and other halogens) using a color comparator. Most men have difficulties with this test because they cannot differentiate between the shades of red the test produces. The test can bleach out at chlorine levels above 10 ppm (which is not even shock level in most pools!). It is accurate to 1 ppm (IF you can differentiate the different shades of red produced.) It can test both free and total chlorine so combined chlorine can be found by the formula TC-FC=CC

FAS-DPD stands for Ferric Ammonium Sulfate -- N,N-diethyl-paraphenylenediamine
This test does not use a color comparator but is a titration test (like the tests for Total Alkallinity and Calcium Hardness) with a distinct endpoint color change from bright pink to colorless. Even people who are colorblind find this test easy to do. This test will not bleach out at chlorine levels as high as 50 ppm with an precision of as much as .2 ppm. (Comes in handy when you want to try and kill algae and it requires you to keep your FC levels at 15 or 20 ppm!) It test for free chlorine and combined chlorine directly. If you want to know your total chlorine it would be FC+CC=TC.

All things considered the FAS-DPD test is much easier to do and produces much more accurate results and is worth every penny extra it costs!

[iwannapool]

Thanks for all replies. Without an understanding of what's involved with these water tests it's hard to tell what you need and what you don't. Thanks, again.