Hi guys and gals,

I have an 18x33 pool that is hard plumbed with 1.5" pipe and I have a 1.5 HP superpump with a cartridge filter. Last summer my salt system and sand filter capped the bed. The sand filter needs the fingers replaced, so that is not a big deal. The SWG though.. what a mess. I got a Aqua Trol from CL and got a few years out of it, but i believe the control board is bad because I took the cell to Leslies Pool shop and they tested it and it was good. So I am looking to replace the entire thing. Now, I am torn between the Hayward SAS, Aqua Trol and Aqua Rite with the 25k cell. I run the pool from late May to September, about 4 months total. I will be in my house for 9 more summers, so which one should I go with?

Thanks

Scott