One way to tell if you're catching anything is to backwash and see what kind of crud comes out of the filter.
I find that cleaning up that first load of fine dead algae dust is a legthy process, during the summer, when the pool's used, we tend to get on top of issues right away before they get big, but that spring cleanup tends to be big, you have a lot of inert dirt in your pool too, just hink, 6-8 months uncovered collecting all that dust that lands on it, during the summer, that dust is removed almost immediately because of filtration, during the winter, it just settles in/on the pool.
I let mine run with the barracuda for about 3-5 days straight, the water is milky looking the whole time and things don't look better, but my pressure guage just keeps rising and rising telling me it's building up a good layer of filth in there, I try not to backwash because a dirty filter works better than a clean one (poconos' DE trick is based on the same priciple). I use DE in the summer to "pre clog" my filter, but don't during spring cleanup because there's enough dirt to do the job instead of the DE.
I'm on year 5 now, still the same Zeobrite as year one, have no plans of changing it, I guess I'll have to if I ever lose a lateral, but aside form that, I doubt I'll ever change the media out.
Bookmarks