Reviews of Bioguard swimming pool chemicals?

[Bardo213]

Hi all. I purchased a home with a 16x32 in ground pool last year. Ended up needing a new liner after this winter which should be completed this coming weekend. Every pool store around me sells and recommends Bioguard products. Any input or feedback on this? I know from looking around that chlorine is chlorine, however I'd like something that, like Bioguard, claims to have minimal up keep on my end. Thanks

[PoolDoc]

I know from looking around that chlorine is chlorine, however I'd like something that, like Bioguard, claims to have minimal up keep on my end.

If you just want a product that claims to have minimal upkeep, there are many choices, but Bioguard would certainly be at the top of anyone's list for having claimed, for years, to be the best and the easiest.

Of course, if you want something that actual DOES provide minimal upkeep, rather than simply CLAIMS to do so, you'll have to look a bit further.


Here's are some typical examples, which may help you decide:

12 lbs BioGuard Balance Pak 100 @ PoolGeek for $13 (+ $10 S&H)
Bioguard carefully labels BP-100 as containing "100% sodium hydrogen carbonate".

6 lbs BioGuard Balance Pak 200 @ PoolGeek for $12 (+ $10 S&H)
Bioguard identifies the product as "sodium carbonate"

12 lbs BioGuard Balance Pak 300 @ PoolGeek for $22 (+ $10 S&H)
I think Bioguard identifies the product as "calcium chloride"


13.5 lbs Arm & Hammer Baking Soda @ PoolGeek for $6.44 (+ $0.60 sales tax)
A & H identifies the contends as "sodium bicarbonate".

3.4 lbs Arm & Hammer Washing Soda @ Walmart for $3.24 (+ $0.30 sales tax)
A & H identifies the contends as "sodium carbonate".

50 lbs store brand calcium chloride @ Lowes for $18 (+ $1.67 sales tax)
But, unless you have a concrete pool . . . you don't NEED calcium chloride.


Now, I've heard BioGuard dealers *fiercely* argue that sodium hydrogen carbonate was not the same thing as sodium bicarbonate. But, I'll quote Wikipedia's article on sodium bicarb:

Sodium bicarbonate or sodium hydrogen carbonate is the chemical compound with the formula NaHCO3

Put simply, BioGuard line is the 'premium' chemical line for BioLab pool chemicals. The BioGuard chemicals are packaged more nicely, with the most sophisticated graphics and layout of any current brand. The BioGuard 'Alex' is . . . well, I'll let BioGuard tell you, with this quote from their 'benefits of being a BG dealer page':

One of the best ways to sell BioGuard products is through our exclusive, cutting-edge water-testing tools ALEX® and Accu-Scan®. ALEX is revolutionary software that analyzes test results, figures proper treatment and yields product suggestions and instructions. Accu-Scan is the actual unit that reads the test strip using color reflectance. Nobody else in the industry offers faster or more impressive and precise water testing system.

ALEX has been revolutionary at SELLING BioGuard products since the 1980's. It is indeed both very fast and very precise, with results to the nearest 10 ppb (0.01 ppm). It offers suggestions and instructions that are amazingly effective . . . at selling products that pool owners do not need! And though it's precise (many decimals) it's often horrendously inaccurate. But all that precision (decimals) creates the "impression" of an authoritative test results that is effective at SELLING more chemicals.

And, the inaccuracy helps even more, since if ALEX doesn't sell you something on the first pass, just let them test your water again, and you'll get ALL NEW RESULTS that will recommend more, and different chemicals!

And if that doesn't work, the ALEX program will sell you chemicals to CREATE problems, where none existed before. The most common case, are print-outs telling pool owners to add large quantities of BOTH baking soda and calcium chloride. Doing so will turn your pool into a milk-looking mess almost instantly! We've had new forum users desperate to understand what was wrong with their pool, when the only problem was that they'd followed the ALEX printout to the letter! (And then the dealer sold them "clarifier" to help them clean up the mess ALEX had created!)

A number of years ago, 3 members here got together and all went to their regular dealer together, all carrying their water sample bottles filled with pool water. All three got different results, and a different prescription from ALEX . . . even though they'd all three filled their samples from a single pool!

Get a K2006 . . . and test it yourself => http://pool9.net/tk/

[Bardo213]

Thanks for the responses. I had the liner done today, and the pool company ended up filling the pool up roughly half way since they said they needed to in order to make sure the liner laid correctly (I guess). The pool is 23,000 gallons, and I had planned on using the SS recipe to fill. Now that there is already water in there, how should I proceed? I have bleach and stabilizer that I purchased from Sams. I will pick up the up borax tonight. Should I test the water first in order to give you more info? I do have the K 2006 kit. Thanks in advance.

[PoolDoc]

It's a good idea to test your fill water, so you know what you're working with. Don't test CYA -- there's none in well or city water, and there are only a very limited number of CYA tests in the K2006.

You can follow the SS recipe for up to 2 months on a large pool. After that, you'll need to switch to the standard test & adjust approach.

[chem geek]

And if that doesn't work, the ALEX program will sell you chemicals to CREATE problems, where none existed before. The most common case, are print-outs telling pool owners to add large quantities of BOTH baking soda and calcium chloride. Doing so will turn your pool into a milk-looking mess almost instantly! We've had new forum users desperate to understand what was wrong with their pool, when the only problem was that they'd followed the ALEX printout to the letter! (And then the dealer sold them "clarifier" to help them clean up the mess ALEX had created!)

This post is an example of this where adding Balance Pak 100 and Balance Pak 200 together increased pH and TA to make the pool cloudy. Then Smart Shock was added which had copper in it that turned the cloud green.

[CarlD]

Balance Pak 100 = Sodium Bicarbonate==>Baking soda
Balance Pak 200 = Sodium Carbonante ==>Washing soda
Balance Pak 300 = Calcium Carbonate (basically, what's in Tums.)

[chem geek]

Balance Pak 300 = Calcium Carbonate (basically, what's in Tums.)

Actually, according to this MSDS, Balance Pak 300 is calcium chloride, not calcium carbonate (which does not dissolve very quickly except in acid). It's the same as Peladow (90% calcium chloride) and similar to Dowflake (68% calcium chloride).

[CarlD]

Actually, according to this MSDS, Balance Pak 300 is calcium chloride, not calcium carbonate (which does not dissolve very quickly except in acid). It's the same as Peladow (90% calcium chloride) and similar to Dowflake (68% calcium chloride).

Thanks for the correction, Richard.

Of course, the point is they are selling very ordinary chemicals at 3x or 4x what you can buy them at when you go to the supermarket or CostCo. Even the fanciest market in my town sells both borax and washing soda for about $1/lb.