Success!! I can see the bottom of the pool! Still has a light haze (no sparkle yet) but TONS better than it was.

New, quality filter did wonders along with 2.5 lbs of CYA, 3/4 gal of bleach =
5.0 chlorine, 7.2 ph, 170 alk, 50 cya.

Chlorine is up and AK still high, but LOOKS a whole lot better and should be much easier to manage.

Thanks for all the help!