Trust the Taylor kit's results.

I wouldn't think that in your area you would need CYA higher than 60-70. People who we sometimes suggest that to are those living in the really hot areas of the south. I think you're probably fine with 60-70. However, if you want to bump your CYA up some, you can but if you do so, you'll need to run higher chlorine levels per the Best Guess Chlorine Chart.