Feeling a little electricity in the pool

[PoolDoc]

Moose,

You're a science teacher. Think about what you're reporting! A properly installed bonding system turns the entire pool and deck into an open top Faraday cage. To the extent that there is ANY potential between one element in the cage, and another member . . . to that extent, the cage is defective.

Granted, under extreme currents (lightning!), there will be a potential across the cage. But even then, someone IN the pool should be in a very high resistance path, compared to all the other available low resistance paths.

Pool was WELL bonded and there was no current leak from the house or pumpworks

In fact, unless I'm really missing something here, your friend's story proves that the pool was NOT well bonded. Having passed inspection (in the past) and being well bonded (today) are NOT the same things!

Lots of things that 'pass inspection' don't remain safe or effective. Conduit grounds have nearly killed me twice, once in a restaurant under the dishwasher (I'm a plumber, and used to do commercial service) and once in a pool room . . . even though both systems passed NEC inspection. (I *hate* EMT and LMT conduit grounds -- I'd outlaw them, if I could! They ALWAYS fail.)

[msumoose]

I get ya, but it still happened! I believe that the builder of the pool bonded everything but the pool. Lights, stair rails, etc, but not the pool itself, and the quickest way to ground was the pool or the handrail (whichever way you want to see it)...and of course, all I had was a visual inspection, and could see the bonding wire and lugs on the visible stuff. All was done correctly, and he had assurances from the builder that it was in spec.

The removal of the old phone line fixed the issue though...

I see in my work that since the popularity of SWCG's the bonding has gotten MUCH better, I guess putting current IN the pool makes some people a little "BOND HAPPY!)

[PoolDoc]

I get ya, but it still happened!

All was done correctly, and he had assurances from the builder that it was in spec.

The first quote contradicts the second one.

If everything HAD been done correctly, then the events you described would NOT have happened! Bonding creates an electrical equipotential area. In fact, the full name for bonding IS "equipotential bonding". Equipotential means, you've created an area where the voltage potential is the same everywhere.

A bonded pool area MIGHT be at 300V above / below ground (ie, 220 AC), but within the area EVERYTHING would be at the SAME potential, and you could NOT get shocked, for the same reason a bird on a wire doesn't get shocked: the on the birds left may be a 10KV transmission line, but so is the line on the right, and there is NO difference.

Let me say it again: if a pool is CORRECTLY bonded, you CANNOT be shocked while you are completely within the bonded area. You MAY be shocked when you move from one area to another by, for example, stepping off the deck. But, if you are INSIDE the bonded area, and you get shocked you know TWO things:
1. There is a wiring or voltage problem somewhere
AND
2. The pool is not correctly bonded.

Bonding is PRECISELY intended to prevent the situation in #1 (bad wiring, say in the lights) from shocking people.

People constantly confuse bonding and grounding, even though they are completely distinct. Grounding means tying something to ground potential; bonding means creating an equipotential zone (which the ground is not, because it is a high resistance conductor, allowing local variations in what the "ground potential" actually is). You CAN *ground* a bonded area, but it's also possible to have a bonded area at 1000V above ground. (In actual fact, because of the way pools are constructed, most bonding cages are intrinsically grounded to 'earth' potential.) You can ALSO tie the bounding GROUND to the wiring COMMON, so that there are NO local variations in ground potential in the pool area. (On the other hand doing this can create ground loops, but let's leave that alone, for now. In any case, it's almost impossible to BOND a pool, without tying the bond field both the earth ground AND to the wiring common.)

But, AGAIN: If you get shocked, while you are IN your pool OR ON your deck, from anything other than a MASSIVE current flow (transmission line falling into the pool; lightning, etc.) THEN you KNOW that the bonding is NOT correct.

[kelemvor]

I think that the concepts of bonding and grounding are being confused here. Bonding would prevent a difference in potential between the various gear that is bonded together (pump, light, pool, ladder etc). There should also be at least one earth ground on the bonding line. It sounds to me like there is really a difference of potential between the ground its-self and the bonded pool gear. Possibly because the earth ground for the bonding setup was sunk near the pool pump equipment and there is a difference in potential between that location in the earth and the location where this person's pool deck is at. I'm not sure if it's really possible to bond concrete, is it? It might be worthwhile to sink another deep earth ground to the bonding line near the pool and/or decking to try and solve this particular problem. Or it could certainly be a faulty bonding line like Pooldoc said in the first place.

Another thought I had was that if the setup has any significant age, the ground rod could have simply corroded enough that it's no longer serving it's purpose.

[BigDave]

Bonding should bond the water in the pool as well as every piece of metal and all other conductive material (reinforced concrete is quite conductive) close enough to the pool that a someone could touch it and the pool at the same time. The bond is there to force all these objects to the same potential (voltage) by carrying the current of any difference with almost no resistance. The OP here clearly has a bonding problem as did msumoose's friend.
I'm not sure Kelemvor, if driven grounds connected to the bond would help or hurt, they represent additional sources of stray voltage. Some codes require pool bond to be connected to driven ground, some do not. My non-expert opinion: the bond must carry the current of the voltage differences around the pool but should not be used to equalize potential accessed by driven grounds.