If you are going with the EcoStar, then I would recommend the ProLogic or AquaPlus controller/SWG all in one unit. Also, make sure you get the 3-year warranty when you purchase from a single vender. If Hayward won't give you the extended warranty, then there is always Pentair which seems to get better reviews on the forums. But I have Hayward as well and have been happy with the equipment.