In Ben's sticky on lowering TA (http://www.poolforum.com/pf2/showthread.php?t=191), he says that the 4 carbonate-ish (my term) players in the mix are :
bicarbonates (-HC03)
carbonates (=CO3)
carbonic acid (H2CO3)
carbon dioxide (CO2)
at high pH, the carbonate alkalinity is "in the form of carbonates: there is NO bicarbonate and NO carbonic acid"
and that at low pH, the carbonate alkalinity is "carbonic acid + carbon dioxide, with NO carbonates and NO bicarbonates"
Now, I will be the first to admit that I am not highly chemistry-oriented, so I don't always expect to grasp all of it. To visualize this in my own little empty head, I made a graph, of sorts...
It isn't graphed to any real numbers, it is just supposed to indicate that CO3 is high at high pH, H2CO3 is high at low pH, and I am guessing that the CO2 may increase as the pH drops, but I don't know that. Like I said, it is supposed to be an indicator/visual aid only.
What I am having difficulty with, is this: How do the bicarbonates fit in? They don't seem to be there in either high or low pH cases. Can someone tell me the relationship with it?


Reply With Quote

Bookmarks