+ Reply to Thread
Page 5 of 6 FirstFirst ... 3 4 5 6 LastLast
Results 41 to 50 of 51

Thread: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

  1. #41
    prh129 is offline Lifetime Member Widget Weaver prh129 0
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Rehoboth, MA
    Posts
    258

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    Normally, you have a ground wire so that if there is a failure, the electricity has a path to ground that it goes to instead of going through you. If you have a ground wire tied to the pool and let's say the electric wire from the pump severed and touched the pool then electricity would flow through the pool to ground and if someone was in the pool then it would seem like they would be electrocuted. Without the ground wire, the pool would go up to the line voltage but no current would theoretically flow so someone in the pool shouldn't be harmed. This matches John T's explanation of the purpose of bonding. However, the bonding wire just sits on the ground so the pool is not totally isolated but I'm guessing the amount of current that can flow to ground is much less through a thinner wire sitting on the ground wire than a fat rod buried in the ground.

    In either case if your pool was hit by lightning I think anyone in it would be toast.

    If the above is true then I would remove the connections to ground.

    Peter

  2. #42
    matt4x4 is offline Lifetime Member Verb Herder matt4x4 2 stars matt4x4 2 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    .
    Posts
    819

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    If you're in your pool, and the severed cable hits the pool or the motor armature shorts or whatever, you DO NOT FRY, because EVERYTHING is BONDED back to the motor armature in a loop, including the ground post which ends up just becoming an extension of the pool wall or anything else metal that is bonded, it has NOTHING to do with GROUNDING in THIS particular scenario, the only time the rod is beneficial above and beyond being a metal stick in the ground is when lightning strikes....when lightning stikes, you don't need a bond, and the system now works as a lightning ground.
    Remember that with or without a ground ROD, you still have a ground that is connected in the the exact same way, the only difference being it is a thin wire that runs back to the house, this wire cannot withstand the current produced by lightning, but is fine for any malfunction related to your equipment.
    So, the only reason you're putting in a ground rod is to allow you to ALSO deal with safely dissipating the IMMENSE current produced by lightning which the little wire running back to the house is UNABLE to do for you. In my opinion, it's a pretty good reason to do so.....but hey, you only live once.

    If Grounding your pool properly is a safety concern, then pumps and lights should not ship with ground wires, you would not have to run a grounded circuit to your pool, and last but not least you would have to build your pool on top of something like a rubber membrane or pink styrofoam that stretches beyond the reaches of the pool wall because the ground it's built on, the same ground the wall channels sit on is definitely not an insulator.
    Last edited by matt4x4; 07-05-2006 at 04:35 PM.

  3. #43
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    127

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    You guys are going to kill me...........I think I'm following, but can you just answer this question:

    Do we need to change the setup or is it fine? I can't tell if I'm going to die or not from the explanations. ROFL!

  4. #44
    prh129 is offline Lifetime Member Widget Weaver prh129 0
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Rehoboth, MA
    Posts
    258

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    Denanbob - I don't have the expertise to tell you what to do here so I won't.

    I was thinking about this some more and if the pump is double insulated then I don't believe that the bonding wire connects to the circuit ground back to the panel.

    Anyway, if lightning hits an AG pool, it's made of metal and it's sitting on the ground so the lightning has a direct path to ground through the pool so it shouldn't need to flow through the ground wire back to the panel. I don't think a grounding rod would provide any more safety in the case of a lightning strike (or other situation). If it did then why wouldn't the electrical code (article 680) specifically call for it?

    Peter

  5. #45
    matt4x4 is offline Lifetime Member Verb Herder matt4x4 2 stars matt4x4 2 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    .
    Posts
    819

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    I would ground the pool to the rods, reason being, if lightning ever does strike and you do NOT have rods, under certain scenarios, it is not grounded well enough just by sitting on the "ground" (meaning dirt). if the "ground" is not wet enough, lightning will not travel into it, it's the moisture content in the "ground" that allows it to act as a grounding point, the dirt itself does pretty much nothing, the rods ensure that you are always grounding through soil that has moisture content, so essentially they are just an extension of all your pool metal into permanently wet/damp "ground".
    Without the rods, If lightning strikes during a dry spell, the path of least resistance would be through the circuit ground wire (the thin one) back to the panel and into the grounding rod located at the house, however, this path would only be available to the lightning for a mili second because that's all it would take to burn up the wire, at that point you would no longer have a path to ground - therefore, to be absolutely safe, I would use the ground rods.

    Grounding your pool through ground rods has absolutely NO effect on the bonding aspect of the pool, bonding is a completely different procedure meant for a completely different scenario, but still brings everything back to a ground rod at your house.
    Bonding anything metal is done to ensure that if this metal becomes energized, it is safely taken to ground, eliminating any electrical potential within that item. However, bonding is not done for lightning strikes, it is done for electrical malfuntions where the current is much lower and will not cook your #12 wires. Metal things INSIDE your house will likely NEVER get struck by lightning, metal things outside of your house are always at risk, I looked at my Natural Gas tank located outside my house last night, I found a #8 wire leading directly to ground from the tank's body. I looked at my Electrical meter outside my house, another #8 directly to the house ground rod. When I installed my Satellite dish, it was not just recommended, it was specified to ground it within a certain number of feet otherwise the warranty would be null and void.
    My pool instructions specified it as well, yes, it's not electrical code, but the pool manufacturer has nothing monetary to gain from this recommendation, yet they still recommend you do it.

    BTW - Anything bonded within your house like plumbing, gas lines etc., goes DIRECTLY to the house ground rod through a minimum #8 wire, why would it be such a bad thing to do the same at the pool instead of relying on a thin #12 wire to bring it all the way back to the house just to let the #8 located there bring it to the ground rod?
    The code specifies that a ground rod is NOT required, however, that does not mean you cannot install one, codes are MINIMUM giudelines you have to follow, however, like anything, going above and beyond the call of duty is not a bad thing.
    I live in Canada, our electrical codes are different, usually our construction codes are stricter that those in the USA, I have not had time to look up our electrical codes on this issue, but this is going to make me do so as soon as i can, I WILL post back with my findings on that.

  6. #46
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    127

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    My DH just got done sledgehammering 10ft copper rods into the ground at six different points around our pool. I don't even know HOW we would begin to get those out. We searching for how to ground a pool and this is what we found. Now I'm finding out this may not be the case. He also put little copper connectors at the base of each of our posts/pillars that hold the pool up. He then is threading #6 copper wire through each connector and ground all the way around the pool. So it will go connector/ground rod/connector/ground rod, etc................Please tell me we don't have to rip this all out. If anything, is it just overkill?
    Matt - so you're saying we're just fine with what we've done even though it's not required by code, right? Thanks sooooooooo much for the great explanations. I appreciate you taking the time to type all that out.

  7. #47
    prh129 is offline Lifetime Member Widget Weaver prh129 0
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Rehoboth, MA
    Posts
    258

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    I would be interested in getting JohnT's take on this as he seems to have a lot of experience with this.

    Although #8 is heavier than #12, I'm not convinced that it too would not be able to handle the current from a lightning hit. Lightning rods use #4 so I suspect that the pool bonding connections do not take lightning into consideration.

    In an earlier post, JohnT talked about not grounding a circuit at more than one point. I understand the concept of current flowing through earth in this case but I don't know what the implications are.

    I'm just trying to understand the concepts so since this thread started with a discussion about codes for wiring it seems appropriate to do so.

    Peter

  8. #48
    matt4x4 is offline Lifetime Member Verb Herder matt4x4 2 stars matt4x4 2 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    .
    Posts
    819

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    Well, this is a real grey area with the NEC, first off, when it comes to bonding and grounding, they are two different things, but are essentially the same thing.

    Bonding means the connecting of metal object together. But in order to do proper bonding, the bonding has to tie to the Ground rod of the electrical system, otherwise the bonding is incomplete and essentailly does nothing other than making everything metal live when an electrical malfuntion occurs.

    Grounding really just means connecting your electrical system's ground to an acceptable grounding location, that being the ground rod.

    Now, I know John said not to ground to numerous points, this is where it gets really vague because the NEC states that you have to but are not limited to having ONE ground rod, one is the minimum, but it is acceptable to have secondary ground rods, they have to be tied together or be connected to common ground.
    Since your pool rod and your house rod are in the same ground, and are connected to the same bonding wire (remeber that 12 guage back to the panel...) they are essentially tied together twice, once through the 12 guage, once through the ground/dirt. I believe the ground does not count since there is no sure way of telling whether or not the ground the pool sits on is connected to the ground the house sits on unless you have a geological study performed, and another factor is the distance between the two rods which could be so large that the resistance in the ground/dirt becomes big enough to make them two different grounds.

    From what I can get out of the code (interpretation) you are doing NOTHING wrong by adding a ground rod to the pool, you are actually just ensuring a good solid working ground connection at that location exists, this really just comes into play for such acts as lightning, I'm not sure what I have for guage at the pool ground rod, but it's easily the thickness of a finger, looking at the other metal objects that are grounded around the outside of my house, it looked like #8 was the common denominator for what was used, then again, that's probably also the spool the electrician had for doing the inside bonding, so he just used it on the outside grounds as well.
    I can tell you one thing, the house we have (custom built 3 yrs before we bought it) was extremely overbuilt, everything, and i mean everything, was absolutely perfect when we got it, there were a lot of "don't need it but nice to have it" things and the "wow, now that's a good idea" things, so it makes me think it was all done above and beyond the basic requirements.


    It's all very confusing, it all ties to ground in the end,

  9. #49
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    ny.
    Posts
    33

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    May I add.....you shouldn't be in the pool during a lightning storm. Sorry couldn't help myself.

  10. #50
    matt4x4 is offline Lifetime Member Verb Herder matt4x4 2 stars matt4x4 2 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    .
    Posts
    819

    Default Re: AG Pool wiring and other headaches

    Roxy - I totally understand that, but when parents are out and teenagers are home, common sense sometimes goes out the window! Alsao, sometimes, it seems like a thunderstorm is a loooong ways away, you're in teh pool, starting to think it might be time to get out because of the approaching storm, when BANG, a rogue lightning hit. I understand it's probably a 1 in a billion chances, but hey, dung happens....

+ Reply to Thread

Similar Threads

  1. New house, new pool, new headaches.
    By jcgeorge in forum Pool Startup, Shutdown, & Winter Operation
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 07-27-2012, 03:18 PM
  2. Tips on removing pool light wiring from conduit??
    By imamachine in forum In-Ground Pool Construction and Repair
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 06-20-2012, 06:18 PM
  3. Too much chlorine, headaches, nausea
    By mida68 in forum Salt Generators (SWCG) & other Chlorine Feeders
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 04-01-2007, 07:39 PM
  4. wiring for a heat pump(new IG pool)question
    By freddyttt in forum Pool Equipment & Operations
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 09-08-2006, 12:01 PM
  5. Pool Heater Wiring Issue
    By TexasPoolGuy in forum Pool Equipment & Operations
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 08-01-2006, 12:32 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts