How to test bottled bleach?

[KurtV]

Here's another:
I bought several 5 gal. carboys of 12.5& last summer and I've still got one unopened that's been in an unheated garage. I'll be testing it to see how it stands now.

That's what I don't get. Why test it? Wouldn't it be much easier to dump a gallon (or half gallon or whatever makes sense in your pool size) in the pool, wait 15 minutes, and then test your pool water (as you probably do once a day or so anyway), and see how the addition affected your pool water? You can very easily estimate what percentage of chlorine the bleach was using bleachcalc from that. Certainly to an accuracy that's more than adequate for our purposes.

Is testing your bleach an interesting exercise? Sure. Is it necessary? Nope. Is it even helpful? Not very. And it is more hassle than the alternative.

[CarlD]

That's what I don't get. Why test it? Wouldn't it be much easier to dump a gallon (or half gallon or whatever makes sense in your pool size) in the pool, wait 15 minutes, and then test your pool water (as you probably do once a day or so anyway), and see how the addition affected your pool water? You can very easily estimate what percentage of chlorine the bleach was using bleachcalc from that. Certainly to an accuracy that's more than adequate for our purposes.

Is testing your bleach an interesting exercise? Sure. Is it necessary? Nope. Is it even helpful? Not very. And it is more hassle than the alternative.

Then don't do it. Seriously. Everybody has their own way of doing things. If this doesn't suit you, don't do it.

Me, I prefer to know what I'm dumping into my pool before I dump it in. I prefer to know how much I need to get the effect I want. But that's me and that's my pool.

If it doesn't suit you or your pool care system,
then just don't do it.

[KurtV]

Sorry, Carl. I thought we were having a discussion about how to test chlorine strength, how accurate that testing is, and the usefullness and efficacy of such testing.

I think I was advocating the traditional poolforum position; that pool care should be effective, simple, and affordable.