Pool Timers - I need to replace

[Poconos]

Just something to consider about any electronic device, especially ones that are on an unfused, high current line. Lightening. Circuit breakers don't count as they are too slow acting. Unless you get a direct hit, the simple and cheaper mechanical timers are pretty immune. Manufacturers do consider power line spikes to varying degrees, but in any case, spikes and electronics don't get along well together. Another issue is wide temperature swings on electronic components if they are so exposed. I know they have a warranty but that is probably one year at most and anything after that, you eat it. Just my opinion.
Al

[tclemmer]

Good point. Had not thought about that. I can see the benefits of the mechanical timers: Cheaper, Robust to power flucuations etc, longevity.

The electronic versions only have one real benefit: Progammability.

Thanks for your input. I was hoping that someone that actually has used the electronic timers would have something to say, but I guess the lack of people that have used them on this forum makes a statement itself.

Tom

[hinejs]

Good point. Had not thought about that. I can see the benefits of the mechanical timers: Cheaper, Robust to power flucuations etc, longevity.

The electronic versions only have one real benefit: Progammability.

Thanks for your input. I was hoping that someone that actually has used the electronic timers would have something to say, but I guess the lack of people that have used them on this forum makes a statement itself.

Tom

I sell the tightwatt timers. Its a convenience thing. The good old Intermatics are fine too. Have you considered upgraded to automation with a wireless remote?

[tclemmer]

I read some about the x10 home automation stuff but have not looked into any wireless stuff.

I think I am going to save money and just look into a replacement mechanical timer.

Thanks anyway

Tom

[hinejs]

I'm a big fan of the automation by Pentair. Easy to setup and easy to use.

I also understand that its a considerable investment. Thats why I sell so many of the universal replacement timer mechanisms for the intermatics.

Its a fairly simple 20 minute replacement. You'll want to throw the circuit breaker for the pool equipment first. Be sure you've got a good solid ground on your timer, and that you get the plastic wire gaurd back on.

[MarkC]

Another good think about mechanical timers is if the power goes out for any length of time they don't care and when the power does come back on they will just pick up where they left off. The time might be a few hours off of the correct time but the pumps will still turn on. I don't know what kind of backup the digital has.

[tclemmer]

The two I asked about both have battery backup. But I am going to replace with mechanical.

Tom