Update: I had a chance to look at it Sunday (finely finished moving). The gasket was mangled. I was expecting pieces to go everywhere when I took it apart and was surprised by how simple it was. Removed the silicone that had held the old gasket in, cleaned it up super glued the new one in.. put a little lube on it and put the screws back in. Took less than an hour which included drying time, picking up the gasket, and hitting the grocery store for milk.

Thanks for the help guys!