Marie,

Well, this is a topic of hot debate as parts of this thread shows. Though the thread was mostly concerning the issue of why a higher CYA level is required for an SWCG system, the answers to that question also relate to why a lower chlorine level may be OK in such a system. Most people find that their CC remains at 0 in an SWCG system and I took a poll recently that showed that this is almost true with manual chlorination though some shocking (1-3 times per season) is typical. At least one user with SWCG reported having algae if not following Ben's table, but most found no problem using a lower amount.

So the jury is still out on this one though I'm leaning towards the belief that the continual shocking of a subset of the water plus fairly even continual chlorine dosing allows one to run at lower FC in an SWCG system.

Richard