Richard & Poolsean,

This is so great for those of us on the edge of understanding it all. Its like reading Scientific America - I don't understand most of it but it sure stretches the mind.

The ONE thing that hasn't been addressed in your analysis, Richard, is the fact (using the term loosely) that almost everyone using a SWG with fairly well balanced water reports CC at 0 all the time. This is not true (I believe) of those that use bleach to maintain normal FC, at some point they will get a buildup of CC and have to shock (which is another interesting thread you are involved in!). This would seem to support the idea that the SWG is "super-shocking" in the cell and it must be some larger percentage of the water that passes through the cell than you are calculating.

In thinking about this though, you did say that it might take a couple of days to "shock" all of the water in the pool, perhaps this is happening and is "good enough" to keep the CC reading at or close to zero. I am wondering why or whether this information is available in Austrailia where they have been using these systems for a lot longer than here (at least for non-commercial pools).