salt water chlorinators: Zodiac LM2-24

[tenax]

good question..and one i pondered as well as i watched an auction on ebay a few weeks ago (turned out it went for more than i was willing to pay for it) but, i kept asking myself, why would a person go with an LM2 model versus the newer supposedly much improved LM3 version? so i searched the net trying to find the difference and aside from the housing etc..i found zero information to say why the LM3 is better. maybe someone can shed some light on this so you can get a more informed opinion (even the zodiac company website information didn't tell me what made the LM3 better)

maybe it isn't and it's simply prettier to look at?

[PatL34]

Not sure why you are ignoring the Zeobrite Filtration? It has nothing to do with salt water chlorinator. They both have different functions in pool operations. The filter filters bad stuff, and the chlorinator provides the chlorine.

Or am I missing something/

Pat

[Poolsean]

I agree with Pat, the Zeobrite is filtration. A salt chlorine generator is sanitization.
From what I can see, the cell design of the LM3 is different and allows a higher pressure rating before any damage to the housing. It also allows you to remove the cell cluster for cleaning, rather than taking the whole old style rectangular cell and adding the solution into it.

[Pool_Mike]

Thanks guys. Well I have to make up my decision by Monday(7-10-06).

I talked to my builder one more time this evening about going with the SWG.

He still totally insisted that the chlorineator/zeobrite combo will be at best and less maintance.

He said that the swg is not any easier maintance and said that since swg is all digital that many other things would go wrong. He insisted us going with the original setup and if I dont like it, then go w/ the SwG... then again I think it would be more costly down the road if I do decided to go that route

help help help. decisions....arggghhh!!

[Poolsean]

I think you should go the normal route but make sure they allow for space for the salt chlorine generator installation. This way you'll appreciate the water quality difference and ease of maintenance even more!

Not quite sure what the correlation is between the unit being Digital and "many other things would go wrong".
Digital stereos are certainly alot better than the old analog needle and dial AM radios.
Digital I-pods are certainly better than 8-track tapes (boy am I showing my age).
Digital video cameras are better than Betamax tapes.

I would certainly recommend DIGITAL.
(lol - Ben's gonna kill me for this attemp at a sales pitch)

[Pool_Mike]

I think you should go the normal route but make sure they allow for space for the salt chlorine generator installation. This way you'll appreciate the water quality difference and ease of maintenance even more!

Not quite sure what the correlation is between the unit being Digital and "many other things would go wrong".
Digital stereos are certainly alot better than the old analog needle and dial AM radios.
Digital I-pods are certainly better than 8-track tapes (boy am I showing my age).
Digital video cameras are better than Betamax tapes.

I would certainly recommend DIGITAL.
(lol - Ben's gonna kill me for this attemp at a sales pitch)

Sean,, hey hey are you messing with my mind? I think you meant to say.. go with swg and call it a day, right?

Thanks

[Poolsean]

But of course! You won't regret it. Make sure you get your owners manual, or better yet, if you can download one and read up on it first, you'll be more comfortable with what all the buttons and lights do and indicate.