Tonight I add salt to my non SWG above ground pool

[cleancloths]

I'm lost! WHY are you adding salt to a NON-SWG system? What will it do for you?

[The Raddish]

Many people here on this site and elsewhere claim that adding salt to your pool helps make the water less 'harsh'. The claim is that it is good for the hair and skin, and reduces or eliminates eye burn.

All of these things are attractive to my wife and I, so I figure why not give it a try? After all, it's the same concept used for in-home water softeners, so why wouldn't it work in a pool environment?

[cleancloths]

Not sure I buy that it does anything for you, but your pool already has salt in it. Think about it for a few minutes.

You add chlorine as either sodium hypochlorite or calcium hypochlorite. You add borax, or baking soda or other pH up chemicals. Thus you have Cl ions an Na ions floating around in the water. That is exactly what you get when you add NaCl (salt). These ions are all dissolved in the water. When you add salt you are adding more which may or may not dissolve depending on what levels you all ready have. You may actually create water chemistry problems, not to mention the potential for corrosion on certain metals. Don't think it a good idea.

[Sherra]

Cleanclothes,

There are several "veterans" on the board who have added salt to their non-swg pools with excellent results. Take a look through the Salt Generator forum and you'll find a couple of threads about it. It does no harm to a properly balanced pool, liners, finishes, etc.

[Rangeball]

cleancloths, hundreds, thousands or even hundred thousands of SWG pool owners probably disagree with you.

I added salt to my non SWG pool and the way the water feels while in the pool or after getting out is noticably better, much preferred.

If you have an open mind I recommed you do a search for adding salt. I've had absolutely none of the problems you mentioned, and expect never too. The salt levels I ended up with are less than half those recommended for SWG pools.

[cleancloths]

While it likely has done no harm, it will impact the overall water balance chemistry. Salts act as buffers and you should already be buffered, thus you will end up with slighly salty water - if you like that go for it, but I would never add a chemical that I really don't need.

There are millions of people that claim things do things that they really don't - that does not make them right.

I would be interested in seeing some technical documentation (not just opinions) that adding NaCl to a chlorine sanitized pool has value. Please let me know of a link where I can see that.

Thanks

[waterbear]

While it likely has done no harm, it will impact the overall water balance chemistry. Salts act as buffers
Sodium chloride does not act as a buffer at all, it posses no buffering ability whatsoever!....Buffers are composed of an acid and their correspnding ion such as carbonic acid/ carbonates and bicarbonates or boric acid/borates
and you should already be buffered, thus you will end up with slighly salty water - if you like that go for it, but I would never add a chemical that I really don't need.

There are millions of people that claim things do things that they really don't - that does not make them right.

I would be interested in seeing some technical documentation (not just opinions) that adding NaCl to a chlorine sanitized pool has value. Please let me know of a link where I can see that.
basically all it does is raise the salinity closer to the isoelectric point of the human body which will inrease comfort and feel less harse to the skin and eyes.
Thanks

Hope this helps explain things a bit

[Rangeball]

If you have an open mind I recommed you do a search for adding salt.

Guess not...

[The Raddish]

Cleancloths, I'm not sure I understand your objections here. Many people use salt water chlorine generators to generate chlorine in their pools. They keep a salinity level around 3000ppm. Not all of that salt has been processed into chlorine at one time, so there will be salt in the pool.

Aside from the chlorine generating aspects of the equipment, I gather that the rest of the chemistry is identical to a non-SWG pool. In other words, it has no effect on the rest of the pool chemistry.

I'm shooting for roughly 1/3 to 1/2 the levels of salt for my non-SWG pool. I don't worry at all about corrosion, since everything in a pool is designed to be around chlorine. Since the reason salt is corrosive is because of the the reactance the world has to the chlorine in the salt molecules, there is no 'additional' corrosive effect from salt in the water.

As for a chemical that is not needed, as you have already pointed out, there is already salt in every chlorine pool, just at much lower levels. I don't need salt in my water, but salt in my water will make the water feel better on my skin and hair and eyes. Since my skin and hair and eyes are all important to me, adding salt to my water to make them feel better is a benefit. Since (as you have already pointed out) salt is a 'buffer' and has no adverse effects on the rest of the pool chemistry, I fail to see one single drawback of putting a modest amount of salt (approx. 1000ppm) in my pool water.

For everyone else, I'll post how much difference adding salt to the water feels after a few days of swimming in it.

[cleancloths]

Cleancloths, I'm not sure I understand your objections here. Many people use salt water chlorine generators to generate chlorine in their pools. They keep a salinity level around 3000ppm. Not all of that salt has been processed into chlorine at one time, so there will be salt in the pool.

Aside from the chlorine generating aspects of the equipment, I gather that the rest of the chemistry is identical to a non-SWG pool. In other words, it has no effect on the rest of the pool chemistry.

I'm shooting for roughly 1/3 to 1/2 the levels of salt for my non-SWG pool. I don't worry at all about corrosion, since everything in a pool is designed to be around chlorine. Since the reason salt is corrosive is because of the the reactance the world has to the chlorine in the salt molecules, there is no 'additional' corrosive effect from salt in the water.

As for a chemical that is not needed, as you have already pointed out, there is already salt in every chlorine pool, just at much lower levels. I don't need salt in my water, but salt in my water will make the water feel better on my skin and hair and eyes. Since my skin and hair and eyes are all important to me, adding salt to my water to make them feel better is a benefit. Since (as you have already pointed out) salt is a 'buffer' and has no adverse effects on the rest of the pool chemistry, I fail to see one single drawback of putting a modest amount of salt (approx. 1000ppm) in my pool water.

For everyone else, I'll post how much difference adding salt to the water feels after a few days of swimming in it.

GOOD Points, maybe it won't hurt anything. Won't you end up with white stains on everything once water splashes dry. Also doesn't salt dry out your skin.