In a 25K gallon pool each 2 lbs of stabilizer should raise your Cl by around 20 ppm, but if you backwashed, or had splashout, or drained water from the rains, that could explain why it didn't rise as much as expected. Besides, CYA is a subjective test, and it's pretty much a ballpark estimate, anyway.
So...If I were you, and had trichlor pucks in my possession, I would just chlorinate via trichlor tabs in a floater for now, until the CYA comes up to where you want it. With well water, your pH needs to stay on the low side of the scale, and the trichlor will help you do that, in addition to adding the CYA and chlorine that you need. If you don't want to use trichlor, then you could add another pound of stabilizer and that should get you to around 50 ppm, and then you can continue to use bleach--that decision is really up to you.
Take a look at the "best guess chlorine chart" linked in my sig for the levels of chlorine to maintain for each level of CYA...
Bookmarks