"Holding Chlorine"

[Cookieman]

I'm new to the forum and have seen the phrase "...until the chlorine level holds" in discussions regarding adding chlorine. What does this mean? I just cleared up a green pool by getting chlorine to the shock level in best guess chart(BGC) for 2-3 days. Added the chlorine at night after testing, and tested the next morning. Levels were high in the morning before sunrise, but much lower in evening, even with a CYA of 45-50. Now that pool is clear, I am trying to figure out what is a normal amount of chlorine I must add each day/week to keep it in range on BGC. I always lose PPM from morning to night due to the sunlight.

[Watermom]

It is normal to lose some chlorine during the day. That means the chlorine is doing its job sanitizing your water. With a CYA of 45-50, you need to be adding enough chlorine in the evening to get back to 6ppm. What are you using for your source of chlorine?

[waterbear]

I'm new to the forum and have seen the phrase "...until the chlorine level holds" in discussions regarding adding chlorine. What does this mean?

It means adding chlorine in the evening as the sun goes down and testing it first thing in the morning to to take any chlorine loss from sunlight out of the equation. If there is nothing 'eating' the chlorine you should not be losing any during the night. If it is dropping overnight it is not holding because something in the water is still consuming it (such as algae or ammonia) even if the water looks clear.

"Normal" daily chlorine loss depends on the amount of sunlight the pool gets, the CYA level, the bather load, etc. but anywhere up to about 2 ppm a day is not uncommon.

[Cookieman]

6% generic bleach - gone through 11 gallons since last Thursday just to keep FC level around 6 when I test in morning after adding in the evening. Pool is still clear, but seems like I am having to add to often.

FC goes up pretty good during the night, but drops anywhere between 3-5 ppm during day. I have added 11 gal of bleach since last Thursday just to keep FC around 6. Base on what I have read in the forum, sounds excessive. Should I have to add 2 gal per day to keep it at that level? Thanks for the help.

[waterbear]

If the FC is holding overnight with no appreciable loss and you are losing 3-5 ppm during the day to sunlight then you need to increase your CYA level. If the FC is dropping overnight then there is something in the water consuming it. A full set of test results would be helpful. What is your CYA and do you have any CC?

[Cookieman]

CC usually 0 but every so often it gets to .5, CYA=50, Ph=7.4-7.6; TA=115; Calcium=80. Thought my CYA was high enough such that I should stay off the trichlor tabs. Last night I added 3.5 gal of bleach to raise FC from 2.5 to 14.0 when tested this morning before sunrise. Tonight FC was 6.5.

[Watermom]

That is a pretty big chlorine loss over one day. See if you lose more than 1ppm from sundown to within two hours of sunrise the next day. If so, you are fighting something in your water and need to hold at shock level until you aren't losing more than 1ppm overnight (and have no more than 0.5 CC). If you aren't losing overnight, then you probably need to bump your CYA up some.

[Cookieman]

So to see if I am not losing chlorine overnight would I test at sunset or after, skip the addition of chlorine, and see if it goes down before sunrise? When I have added at sunset or night, it has always been higher the next morning. If I find I am losing more that 1 ppm, are you saying I need to get it to shock levels during the night - as tested in morning? I did that two weeks ago to get rid of a green pool. Added enough bleach each night for FC to be 18-22ppm the next morning. Pool cleared in 3 days and I let it drop back down to best guess chart.

[waterbear]

Add chlorine at night, test (CC should be 0 ppm if there are no problems), test again in the AM. You should have less than 1 ppm FC loss and no CC in the AM. IF you do you need to get the pool to shock level and keep it there until the problem is resolved. Once you have done so you can determine how much FC you lose due to sunlight by testing in the AM and again at sunset to see how much FC you lose during the day. If it is more than 2 ppm then you should bump ypur CYA up in 10 ppm amounts until you minimize your FC loss. Remember to adjust your base FC level according to the best guess chart as you raise the CYA if that is needed.

[Watermom]

Just to add to what Waterbear said, after you add chlorine in the evening, wait a bit to let it circulate and then test.