City or well for fill water

[ivyleager]

Steve,

Go with the City water for the moment

Pat

Why? The well water should do fine (and is free), as lowering high TA is relatively easy using the aeration method.

City water, and the trucks used for transport, can be problematic also.

However, I'd also recommend testing fill/well water to quantify TA, Cal, pH. Always good to know what's entering your pool.

Just my 0.02

CaryB
Go 'Canes!

[StevenW]

Thanks for the replies. I'll test the well and city water tomorrow. Pat, what is a SWC cell? My well water also has the rotten egg smell, which I believe is a high sulfur content.

Ivyleager, our city water here in Fl is ground water and is basically treated well water. They treat it at the water plant with ammonia and Chlorine which is where the Chloramines comes from. Then it's pumped through the city.

Steve

[PatL34]

SWC = Salt Water Chlorinator. Many here call them SWG = Salt water Generator. I prefer SWC.

If you ever get one, do not use the well water while you are circulating as the bad egg smell, hydrogen sulfide can destroy the coating on the cell in no time. Use well water only when filling from scratch, and city water for refilling or topping off.

Pat

[CarlD]

We have city water and the TA regularly is 180-190ppm.

[StevenW]

Well water:
PH 6.8
TA over 300

City water:
PH 7.8
TA 100

I'm assuming I should bite the bullet and pay the water bill and fill/add water with city water. What do you think?
Thanks,
Steve

[samendolaro]

If you have a PYROLOX iron filter (or get one) this will remove the iron and the Sulphur smell. Otherwise I woulldn't put un-filtered florida well water in a pool.

[waterbear]

I live in N. Fl and use city water that has gone through my whole house filtration and softenter system. Nicely deals with the chlorimines (I have NO dectectable TC in my water after the filtration system and NO metals or sulfer...just have a high phosphate level as most of North and Central Florida does but since I have never had algae don't worry too much about it.) The untreaded city water had a definite sulfur smell to it and also high calcium hardness and some chloramines present. TA for my fill water is 110 ppm so I don't have to deal with that probler. Used to live in S. FL and the TA was throught the roof by comparison but there was no sulfer. Still had to deal with the chloromines adn the TA was pretty high.

[PatL34]

The well water pH at 6.8 indicates some hydrogen sulfide gas. If you want to use it for adding or refilling without circulation, wait at least 6-8 hours before restarting circulation. As you don't have A SWC, the only problem I see is if there any metal parts in contact with the water. Samendolaro suggests using a PYROLOX iron filter, which I think is a great idea that I might try myself.

BTW could you also give us your CH and CYA values as well?

Pat

[StevenW]

Well I'm now using city water for fill water since the TA of the well water is 300+. Using PoolDocs "HOWTO: Step-by-Step Guide to lowering your alkalinity" I've been able to bring my TA down to 240 from 300 in about 6 days. Is that about right time wise? I've got good areation going since I came up with a 45 degree adapter for my return on the pump and it's breaking the water surface nicely. Don't know how I'd do it without this forum.
Steve