The o-ring changing is easy. It's getting the unit apart that can be a little difficult.
If the o-ring tore, the ends can get caught/ pinched by the plate they're supposed to seal making the judicious use of brute force about the only way to get the shaft out (though twisting the handle back and forth whilst pulling does help).
Assuming you can get it out change all the o-rings, if one failed who's to say that another won't go next week? Apply a little silicon or Teflon based lube to the new rings (don't stretch them, just gently rub a little lube onto the surface).
If this gives you any trouble - just give a holler.
Bookmarks