My P.O.P. is gone. need help again

[shub_31]

Thanks for the reply. ive done pretty much all that from other members replies. They couldnt understand why my pool was doing what it was. its the clearest its ever been. I dont see how you can go ALL NIGHT WITHOUT LOSING FC. Ex. If you swim til 8pm. Add bleach up to 10ppm you should be guaranteed to lose ppm. The only way you would never loose was if nobody swam for days til you passed that test. I would think you introduce more contaminants every time someone swims. I shocked for 5 days but still lost 1-2ppm. So the experts recommended letting it drift down and see what happens.

[PoolDoc]

OK, some questions:
Are you saying you lose 4 ppm of FC between 8am and noon, with no one in the pool?
If there are people in the pool, who, and how many?
Do they use lotion heavily? Do they have leaky bladders? (Sorry, but it does matter!)

Changing direction:
Have you EVER used anything made by United Chemical: No Mor Problems, Yellow Treat, etc.?
Have you EVER used any other product sold in a 10" - 16" tall plastic jar, containing 1 - 2 pounds of white fine granular material that was supposed to help with algae, or in some other non-specific way, help your pool?

Ben

[shub_31]

Yes there are people swimming. 2 or 3. yes to lotion. no to the rest. I wasnt sure if its normal to start of at 10ppm then drop and not worry about it till evening. Im sure not everyone checks their pool all day and adds chemicals every couple of hours. thanks. I have added some clarifier about 3 weeks ago and some hth algacide weeks ago but quit

[shub_31]

oops. isnt it normal to lose ppm with 90 degree heat and sun even with noone in the pool

[PoolDoc]

Some. Not 4ppm between 8 & noon.

A typical commercial pool with 120,000 gallons and 200 ppd may have to add 5 - 10 pounds of cal hypo 2x per day to maintain good chlorine levels all day. But, that's 16 ppd / 10,000 gallons, where your pool is 1.5 ppd per 10,000 gallons. The only things I can think of are:

1) Your CYA test results are mistaken.
2) You've added bromine without knowing it -- very possible; those products are almost NEVER labeled as bromine or bromide.
3) You've got something causing heavy chlorine demand.

One way to check would be a pool use holiday -- 48 hours with no swimming. On the 2nd day, does in the late PM, test after 1 hour, and test again in the early AM. With 24 hours prior with NO swimming, the chlorine drop overnight should be very small. Then test again, at noon. If it's a sunny day, and you lose more than 20% of chlorine chlorine from sunrise to noon, EITHER your CYA test results are probably mistaken OR you have bromine or iodine in the pool.

If you do have significant chlorine drop from late PM the 2nd day to early AM the third day, I don't know what it could be.

If you have little drop overnight, and 10% or less loss from sunrise to noon . . . we'll need to look at what your swimmers are doing to create such a high chlorine demand.

Ben

Ben

[shub_31]

ive tested cya over and over and its no more than 100. All the kids do use lotion. And im 100% sure I have not added bromine. I just shocked again at 730. No ones been in the pool since 2. Ill check around 830 and check in the mourning. Hopefully no drop. I want to make sure I dont have algae even though Ive never ever seen any other than having a cloudy pool. And like Ive said before, my pool is the clearest its been in a while. Thanks.

[PoolDoc]

To test the way I said, you'll have to keep people out all day Monday and Tuesday till noon, retest Monday night and Tuesday AM and noon.

Ben

[shub_31]

Well, Ijust got back from vacation. No testing for 7 days. Heres what happend. Had a neighbor add bleach every day and the pump was running all the time with solar cover in place.

Sat. Rained all day. Removed 2 inches of water, tested then left.

Sat FC 15ppm
Sun added 3qts 6%
Mon 6qts 6%
Tues she forgot
Weds 3qts 6%
Thurs 6qts 6%
Fri 3qts 6%

I got home sat at 1pm. Tested
FC 7ppm
CC 1ppm.
I really expected FC to be much higher with cover on and no swimming.There was about 1inch of rain added over week. Then I added bleach tested at night. FC 12ppm. This mourning it was 9ppm. Something isnt right. Im gonna test my cya again. I really dont know whats going on. i thought we had it under control.