+ Reply to Thread
Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 28

Thread: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

  1. #11
    waterbear's Avatar
    waterbear is offline Lifetime Member Sniggle Mechanic waterbear 4 stars waterbear 4 stars waterbear 4 stars waterbear 4 stars
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    St. Augustine, Fl
    Age
    70
    Posts
    3,743

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    Quote Originally Posted by CarlD View Post
    The Pool Calculator generates other recommendations, including amounts of Borax and other additives. What is the accuracy of THOSE estimates?
    I have used all the calculations on it and have found it close enough for government work. so to speak. The Borax calc is very much on the money but then again your don't need that much precision. 60 oz by weight of borax and 30 liquid oz of muriatic acid will raise borates to approx 50 ppm in 1000 gallons and keep the pH pretty close to where you started. You really don't need to be more precise than that, IMHO.
    If you are talking about borax for raising pH then NO calculator is going to tell you how much to add. You will need to use a base demand test and use twice the weight of borax as you would soda ash for a specific pH rise as determined by the test. Not rocket science and a lot easier than adding a bit and waiting and testing and adding a bit more and waiting and testing until you 'creep up' on your target pH.
    Retired pool store and commercial pool maintenance guy.

  2. #12
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Lehigh Valley, PA
    Posts
    870

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    Quote Originally Posted by CarlD View Post
    Enjoy swimming with your dogs (BTW, they are something like 30x dirtier than a person who gets in your pool. So 2 dogs is like a load of 60 bathers)

    Wouldn't that depend on the size of the dogs? And their breed? A Chinese Crested is probably a lot cleaner than a bunch of . . . oh, say, Belgians.

    I do appreciate the concept of the China Shop but I'm too old to argue. I've learned that when I'm right, I'm right.

    Those Margaritas were lovely
    Oval 12.5K gal AGP; Hayward 19" sand filter; Pentair Dyn 1 HP 2sp pump on timer
    [URL="http://www.ellerbach.com/Pool/"]My Pool Pages[/URL]

  3. #13
    CarlD's Avatar
    CarlD is offline SuperMod Emeritus Vortex Adjuster CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    North Central NJ
    Posts
    6,607

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    A Chinese Crested is probably a lot cleaner than a bunch of . . . oh, say, Belgians.
    DEFINITELY! Curiously the little one gets a lot dirtier. But she LIKES mud...the swamp rat!

    I do appreciate the concept of the China Shop but I'm too old to argue. I've learned that when I'm right, I'm right.
    Even when you are wrong! (ESPECIALLY when your're wrong! )

    I love a good margarita, with lots of salt. Chilis BEST thing for years was their "El Presidente" margarita using Presidente Brandy with the Tequila. Last one I had, a couple of years back, they ruined. I was heart-broken.
    Carl

  4. #14
    chem geek is offline PF Supporter Whibble Konker chem geek 4 stars chem geek 4 stars chem geek 4 stars chem geek 4 stars
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    California
    Age
    64
    Posts
    2,226

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    In the "Effects of adding chemicals" in The Pool Calculator, what you are seeing is NOT a rounding error. It is instead taking into account the fact that the Trade % of 6% bleach is actually 6.17%. The 6% listed in the ingredients for bleach is a WEIGHT percentage of bleach, but for your simple formula you need a VOLUME percentage of Available Chlorine aka Trade %. There is also a WEIGHT percentage of Available Chlorine and that is also printed on the Clorox Regular bottle as 5.7%.

    Chlorinating liquid almost always uses Trade % (i.e. volume % of Available Chlorine) even though I've seen this percentage listed in the ingredients. Yes, this is all very confusing, but The Pool Calculator assumes that bleach is specified using a % weight of sodium hypochlorite but for its calculations it uses the Trade %. For chlorinating liquid, it assumes the strength is already in Trade %. Now while The Pool Calculator does this correctly in the "Effects of adding chemicals" section, in the FC Now Target section it seems to incorrectly use Weight % for all bleach entries even when they are a high enough % (such as 10 or 12.5) to imply chlorinating liquid that is more likely a Trade %.

    The formulas for these conversions are as follows:

    Trade % = (Weight % NaOCl) * (Specific Gravity) * (Cl2 g/mole) / (NaOCl g/mole) = (Weight % NaOCl) * (Specific Gravity) * (70.9064) / (74.44) = (Weight % NaOCl) * (Specific Gravity) * 0.9525

    Weight % Available Chlorine = (Trade %) / (Specific Gravity)

    The density of 6% bleach is around 1.08 while for 12.5% chlorinating liquid it's around 1.16.

    Yes, this is all very confusing, but fortunately it doesn't matter that much unless you are looking at better than 3% accuracy.

  5. #15
    madwil is offline Registered+ Widget Weaver madwil 0
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    virginia
    Posts
    261

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    BTW, .0525 is 3 sig digits, not four... placeholder 0 doesn't count;

  6. #16
    CarlD's Avatar
    CarlD is offline SuperMod Emeritus Vortex Adjuster CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    North Central NJ
    Posts
    6,607

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    Richard, that's the first good defense I've read of the deviation in the Pool Calculator from the formula. THAT is an explanation I can accept. It also points out there is a potential inaccuracy in the FC section. Naturally, neither the PC nor the formula take into account any degradation or breakdown in the chlorine over time. I'm confident your coefficients are correct but where do they come from. BTW, how many grams/mole are there in CL2 and NaOCl?

    Madwil, I suppose it's a difference of definition but the VARIABLE "Concentration" must be defined as 4 digits to the right of the decimal point because available VALUES can use any of the 4 places...LC would be expressed as .125, while regular bleach is .0525. Each uses only 3 digits, but 4 are still needed.

    Carl
    Carl

  7. #17
    madwil is offline Registered+ Widget Weaver madwil 0
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    virginia
    Posts
    261

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    That's why it's a place holder...
    0's at the end of a number, without decimal places, are not significant.
    0's after the decimal, before numbers, are not significant if 0 precedes the decimal.
    Otherwise, you could call 2 ppm .000002 and say it's 6 sig dig, when it is only 1!
    Consider scientific notation- a.bc x 10 to n power- a.bc is sig, not the location of the decimal point, with regards to accuracy/precision of measurement
    When you mult/div numbers, the lowest number of sig dig in any of the factors is the number of sig dig in the product
    When you add/sub, the number with the highest multiple of 10 becomes you last sig dig (1,250 + 2, is still 1250 for significance...)

  8. #18
    waterbear's Avatar
    waterbear is offline Lifetime Member Sniggle Mechanic waterbear 4 stars waterbear 4 stars waterbear 4 stars waterbear 4 stars
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Location
    St. Augustine, Fl
    Age
    70
    Posts
    3,743

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    People, we are losing sight of the fact that we are talking about a swimming pool and the amount of water in the pool needs to be accurately known (and not rounded off to the nearest 1000 gallons or so) or this all become moot.
    It's a swimming pool, not a science experiment and in the real world we are just splitting hairs here that are not important. Now I am the first one that insists in precision and accuracy when doing a scientific experiment (lest anyone forget I have a very similar scientific background like chem geeks) BUT you need to take in account your largest margin of error (which in our case would be the volume of water in the pool) and not try and get a precision smaller than this limiting factor because it is invalid! Yes, I know that errors are cumulative but if we are talking about errors that differ on such a significant order of magnitude they become insignificant!

    We also have to take into account the precision of our testing methods and any errors introduced by our testing methodology.

    What it boils down to is that the 'guestimate' that CarlD provided of one gallon of liquid chlorine adds approx. it's strength of FC to 10000 gallons of water is about the amount of precision that we can expect in real world situations of pool maintenacne and it is most certainly close enough for our purposes of maintaining a pool.

    (If anyone is old enough to remember using triple beam balances or balance pans remember that the weight is taken after three equal oscillations of the pointer and not when the pointer had come to rest. This is my point, you have to realize what the limit of your precision is.)
    Last edited by waterbear; 06-11-2011 at 11:22 AM.
    Retired pool store and commercial pool maintenance guy.

  9. #19
    Watermom's Avatar
    Watermom is offline SuperMod Emeritus Quark Inspector Watermom 4 stars Watermom 4 stars Watermom 4 stars Watermom 4 stars Watermom 4 stars Watermom 4 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    Charleston, WV
    Posts
    9,345

  10. #20
    CarlD's Avatar
    CarlD is offline SuperMod Emeritus Vortex Adjuster CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars CarlD 4 stars
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    North Central NJ
    Posts
    6,607

    Default Re: New China Shop Topic: How Accurate is the Pool Calculator?

    You don't think arguing is fun???? That's why we have the China Shop.

    There's difference between measuring with something you know is off and correcting for it: "My speedometer always reads 5mph fast"
    and something you believe is correct and isn't "But Officer, I had it NAILED at 55mph on my speedometer, not 65".

    Can't go swimming. It's nasty, cold and raining. Therefore, arguing is a valid alternative source of fun!

    Carl
    Carl

+ Reply to Thread

Similar Threads

  1. Interesting Winter Topic: My Vet's Dog Pool
    By CarlD in forum Pool Equipment & Operations
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 11-16-2010, 12:58 PM
  2. Suggested Sticky Topic
    By jhm in forum Using Chlorine and Chlorinating Chemicals
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 07-10-2010, 08:54 PM
  3. shop vac to remove wrinkles
    By minermom in forum Above-Ground Pool Construction & Repair
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 06-05-2008, 01:33 PM
  4. Pool Shop Testing, used for personal use?
    By KesLongwood in forum Testing and Adjusting Pool Water Chemistry
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 06-16-2006, 01:13 PM
  5. Help! Green pool here is China Grove Texas!
    By mzorola in forum Dealing with Algae & Slime
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 04-24-2006, 08:17 AM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts