My pool loves low TA

When I try to hold a TA of 80, my PH tends to rise faster requiring more frequent acid applications, which brings the TA down to around 50-60...where my pool seems happy and the PH holds a good level much longer??

This is normal behavior if you have high aeration (or low pH or high TA). What is the pH you are targetting? Do you have a waterfall, fountain, spa jets or other aeration feature? Do you have a salt-water chlorine generation (SWG) system?

Also, what is your CYA level and Calcium Hardness (CH) level (if you have a plaster/gunite/tile grout pool)? With that info, I can tell you if you would be running into any trouble with your low TA plus other options, though your pool might be fine as it is.

Richard

It's an 18000 gal. inground pebbletech finish pool. There is a rock waterfall that I have set to run for 5 minutes every couple days to keep the water in the recesses from getting algae. Yes it is a SWG system. I keep the CYA at between 40-50ppm and the salt level at 2600-3200ppm. Calcium is at around 250-300ppm. FC always around 3 and CC always at 0. Water looks beautiful. In the past I've used baking soda to get the TA back up which resulted in the need for acid to reduce PH, which in effect lowered the TA. Kind of a Catch-22 situation. It could be that I use to much acid? I like to use enough to get the PH between 7.0-7.2 so that I go go a few extra days without checking.

The main problem is that you are trying to maintain a low pH of 7.0-7.2. Why is that your target your pH? Normally, you would target 7.4-7.6 and that will be much easier to maintain as there will be less carbon dioxide outgassing (and pH rise) at that pH.

Well not really trying to maintain it that low. Since the PH is always on a steady incline I set it there to give me more time before another acid dose. I add acid at 7.8-8.0. Is this all wrong?

Well, it's not "all wrong", but adding acid to get down to 7.0-7.2 will cause the pH to strongly rise from that point. The rise in pH will slow down as the pH gets higher so setting a target of 7.4 or 7.5 would be better. At the lower TA, you won't see the rise in pH being as rapid and won't have to add as much acid. If you decide to stick with the low TA, you might want to bump up your calcium hardness (CH) a bit closer to 400 ppm though that is not essential (your water is a little more corrosive with the lower TA and having a higher CH compensates for that).

I suggest you take a look at this thread and consider adding 50 ppm Borates (Borax) to your pool. This should allow you to lower your SWG output (since the Borates will kill algae so less chlorine gets consumed) which will lower the tendency of the pH to rise. The SWG generates not only chlorine, but also hydrogen gas and these bubbles pull out the carbon dioxide from your water and that causes the pH to rise. This is why you see less of a problem at lower TA, because there is less carbon dioxide in the water at lower TA (think of the pool as a carbonated beverage!).

What is the recommended level of CYA that your SWG manufacturer says you should have? Is it 70-80 ppm? We have a current controversy as to whether a high CYA of 80 ppm makes the salt cell more efficient. The problem is that it is easy to add CYA and not easy to get rid of it. So using the Borates is probably a better bet.

Richard

Chem_Geek is of course correct about what's going on, but here's a simplification and SLIGHT correction about what to do (sorry Richard :():

By keeping your pH at 7.2 or lower, the waterfall pushes the pH up. You add acid, pH and T/A come down, you run the waterfall, it pushes the pH up without pushing up the T/A as well.

So. I would suggest (and I RARELY do this) that rather than use Borax to raise your pH, you use Washing Soda (Sodium Carbonate). It's the same as "pH UP!" and other pool products that use soda ash to raise pH, but it costs FAR less. Arm&Hammer Washing Soda is usually next to the Borax in the detergent department. We don't usually recommend Soda Ash to raise pH PRECISELY because it raises T/A at the same time as it raises pH.

Alternatively, if you DO use Borax (and there's nothing wrong with that--I use it all the time) then you can equally boost your Total Alkalinity by adding ordinary baking soda (Sodium BIcarbonate).


It's cheaper to use washing soda because, pound for pound it's even cheaper than 20 Mule Team Borax--and you don't have to buy baking soda.

But either way is fine. The Borates, may, as Richard says, help your SWG run effectively at lower chlorine levels, so that may be a good way to go. After all, even if you use Borax and Baking Soda from the supermarket, it's still pretty cheap.

So:
1) NEVER let your pH go below 7.3 unless you WANT to lower T/A
2) Raise pH by adding either Soda Ash (washing soda) or Borax.
3) Raise T/A to over 100 but not over 125 by adding Soda Ash (which you did in 2) ) or adding baking soda.

I agree that if you want to raise pH while also raising TA, then using pH Up / Washing Soda / Sodium Carbonate will do that. It just seems that BillyBumbler's pool has a very strong tendency to rise in pH and that a large part of that is due to aeration from his SWG. I don't see a problem with his operating at a rather low TA level since that does help reduce the pH rise from carbon dioxide outgassing, but as you and I both said, he shouldn't lower the pH so much since that just exacerbates the pH rising problem.

I think you knew this, but just wanted to be clear, that the 50 ppm Borates option is not about using Borates to increase the pH, but rather to essentially add an algicide and another pH buffer to the pool. When initially adding Borates in such large quantities, a LOT of acid will be required to keep the pH constant until all of the Borates are added. I just wish I could be more confident in whether the Borates would help him. It helped waterbear and some others so I presume it could help in this situation.

Richard

On the other hand, higher T/A levels DO tend to stabilize pH, so the out-gassing should be less effective at raising pH when pH is already in the optimal range.

Yes, I did understand about the borates as an algaecide. While it couldn't hoit, I'm not sure it's necessary. Running a T/A of 80 I believe WILL cause bouncing pH--It's just not high enough to stabilize pH adequately.

Carl,

That's the whole counter-intuitive thing about TA. While higher TA would normally have less of a pH swing with a given acid/base introduction, this apparently is not the case when the source of rising pH is primiarly due to carbon dioxide outgassing which occurs at a faster rate at higher TA. These two factors compete against each other, but the outgassing wins out so that there is actually LESS pH rise AND LESS acid demand at lower TA. This is what BillyBumbler is experiencing and is what many others have experienced as well. This thread at post #31 shows the lowering total acid demand AND rate of rise in pH when KurtV lowered his TA to 60. This thread also talks about rising pH and how lowering TA reduced both the rise in pH and the acid demand but this was not that apparent going from 120 to 80. In this thread the lowering of TA to 80 did result in slower pH rise and less acid demand.

So my conclusion is that lowering the TA mostly works at reducing the rise in pH and the amount of acid needed to restore pH. This is, no doubt about it, one of the most counter-intuitive things in all of pool water chemistry, but it does seem to be true -- at least when the primary source of pH rise is due to carbon dioxide outgassing. The pool store advice of increasing TA to reduce pH fluctuations simply doesn't work and actually makes the problem worse when the pH rise is due to the outgassing. Not only will higher TA result in somewhat faster rising of pH, but the acid demand grows even faster.

Richard

Richard,
You may WELL be right, but remember one key factor:
The original poster has been running a pH of 7.0-7.2--EXACTLY the pH we recommend for the aeration to raise pH.

If we get him to 7.5 (for example), the aeration out-gassing should be aborted, shouldn't it?

If however, it still continues when it's that high, then, of course, the alternative of the lower T/A may well be appropriate.

What do you think?

Carl

Yes, I agree with you that he first needs to try having a target of 7.5 and if he still has a problem then he can lower his TA.