New to the forum and in need of assistance

I've been reading this forum for a few weeks now; very helpful information from a lot of knowledgeable people. I'm new here so please have a little patience, as I'm sure some of my questions show my lack of pool care knowledge. I certainly need and would appreciate some advice and guidance.

I have a 17,000 gal inground fiberglass pool, inline cholorinator using 3" tablets. Pump is 1 1/2 HP, filter Hayward cartdrige. I usually run the pump 8-12 hours a day. I've never experienced problems with water chemistry (knowlingly) until this summer. The pool has been turning green on the bottom w/greenish brown residue on the sides. I kept brushing, vacuuming, and cleaning filters and shocking, only to have it return after a day or so. I took a water sample to the local pool store here in San Antonio numerous times (getting a different recommendation each time). Hundreds of $$$ later I'm back to square one. Then I found this forum and immediately went out and purchased bleach, baking soda, borax, Muratic Acid, and CYA from the pool store. I also ordered and just received today the Taylor K-2006 test kit. While waiting on the test kit, I decided to shock the heck out of the pool. I used about 20 bags of shock from Costco over a seven-day period. It did clear the water and break down the Algae, afterwhich I immediately vacuumed the pool and cleaned the filter. While there is no visible algae in the pool, the water line in the skimmer has a ring of dark green junk that I wipe out daily with a paper towel.

Here are the results of my first testing using the K-2006 today.

FC - 2.5
CC - 3.5
PH -7.0
TA - 150
CH - 420
CYA - 0 (I guess, I couldn't see the black dot after about a half inch)

I'm confused about how much of what to punt in first; do I start by increasing the PH to 7.5?

Would appreciate any guidance.

Tideman,
I'm going to guess that your CYA reading isn't right. Two reasons: You've been using tabs (trichlor) and you couldn't see the black dot, you have low CYA if you can still see the dot with the tube full.

I'm no expert but the people here that are and can help you will need to know what stuff the pool store had you put in the pool - chemical names not brand names.

I'll guess that you'll be advised to bring your clorine to shock level and keep it there until you have no more CC and you can maintain a FC level overnight. If your CYA is over a hundred you should probably consider a changing some of your water.

Good Luck!

Hello, Tideman, and welcome to the forum!!

Your first order of business should be to remove anymore trichlor pucks you have in the chlorinator. They do help feed chlorine into the pool, but they also drive pH down (probably why yours is so low but will probably come up on its own after switching to a different chlorine source) and drives CYA high. If you couldn't see the black dot after about 1/2 inch, then your CYA is well above 100, and possibly nearing 200, which is why you're having recurrent algae blooms. Where most people get into trouble with the chlorinators is that they don't understand that as CYA climbs, so must your baseline chlorine levels to make sure that algae doesn't grow. The chlorine level you must attain to reach "shock" level also climbs along with your CYA. IN short, the trichlor use has gotten your CYA out of control, which is causing your problems, so the trichlor needs to go, at least for the rest of this season.

So..you have a decision to make. With your CYA as high as it is, you're going to have to elevate your chlorine to the 25-30 ppm range and sustain that level for as long as it takes for the algae to truly die, as evidenced by clear water, combined chlorine less than 0.5, AND not losing any chlorine when measuring at sundown and again at sunup. This can take several days, and lots and LOTS of bleach. When you do finally get the algae defeated, you're going to have to run your pool at 8-12 ppm of chlorine ALL THE TIME to keep the algae from coming back. I don't know how much more swim time you have, or how feasible it is to drain/replace some water, but the pool will be much easier to clear up and maintain if you can drain/refill 50% or so of the water to bring that CYA down to a manageable level. THen your shock level that you must maintain to clear the algae and the minimum chlorine levels you have to maintain afterward will both be much lower and easier to manage. Just for a point of reference, in a pool your size, it's going to take about 7 1/2 gallons of 6% bleach to attain "shock" level, and will take about 1 quart to raise your chlorine by 1 ppm when calculating how much more to add each time to get back up to that 25 ppm level.

Your calcium level is very high, also--do you have high calcium in your fill water, or is it a result of using cal-hypo to shock? Doing a partial drain/refill will also help get that number down, if it's a result of cal-hypo use. It's high enough that any added calcium can create problems with milky water, which would eliminate cal-hypo as a chlorine source for you if you choose not to drain/refill some water.

Whether you choose to drain/refill or try to manage it the way it is, is up to you, and we'll be glad to help walk you through it, but either way I very very strongly recommend that you switch to bleach (or liquid chlorine, if it's available to you) for your chlorine source at least for the rest of this season. It will assist you in clearing up the pool, but not affect your pH like trichlor, or your CYA or CH like trichlor or cal-hypo will.

You can safely return the CYA to the store, if they'll take it back, as well as the baking soda, unless you'll use it otherwise around the house. (I would see if they'll trade it for liquid chlorine!!) Any CYA addition you need to make in future seasons can happen via your leftover trichlor, and the baking soda is used to raise alk--and yours is high enough.

Let us know what you decide, and we'll all go from there. Again, welcome to the forum, and congratulations on taking control of your own pool!!

Janet

Janet, thanks so much for the very detailed response. I shut the chlorinator off by setting it to zero. Unfortunately, I can't drain any water, as we are currently on water restrictions because of lack of rain, and our water usage is closely monitered. Therefore, large amounts of bleach is my only option for another month or so; I have 12 gallons of 6% on hand. Since I don't need the CYA, I should be able to exchange it for liquid chlorine.

Temperature is still in the mid to high 90's, we should have another six weeks or so before I cover the pool.

Calcium. Our subdivision has community well water managed by a local water company. I just received their annual report listing contaminants and constituents; the reports shows the calcium ppm is 108. And, of course, I did put in about 20 lbs of cal-hypo in the past week.

So, if I understand you earlier response correctly, I need to add 7.5 gals of bleach, monitor morning and evening, and add 1 quart of bleach as need to maintain a shock level of 25-30ppm until I no longer lose chlorine and CC is 0.5 or less.

I have four new filter cartdriges to change out, but I assume it is best for me wait until I get the algae under control.

Thanks much,

Jim

Just to clarify, you need to add 7.5 gallons of bleach, then test and add more at least 2-3 times daily,but as often as possible, to get back up to the 25-30 ppm range. The more consistent you are about keeping it above the 25 ppm level, the faster it will clear. If you let it yo-yo up and down, you're just wasting time, money, and bleach. When you figure out how many ppm you need to add to get back above 25, that's how many quarts of bleach you need--one quart will raise your Cl by 1 ppm. And yes, you need to keep it there until you're not losing any chlorine at night, the water is clear, and the CC is 0.5 or less.

Keep the pump running 24/7 while this is going on, and keep an eye on your filter pressure. You'll need to clean the cartridges as they gunk up with the dead algae. Brushing the pool daily will help, as well.

Good luck, and keep us posted on how it's going!!

Janet

You say that you are on well water. Does the report show any metals in the water?

Thanks Janet, I appreciate your help and will keep you posted.


Watermom: Seems to be very minimal amounts of metals as follows:

aluminum - 0.029ppm
copper - 0.002
nickel - 0.003
iron - 0.034
zinc - 0.055

Jim

I was able to get my chlorine level to hold steady between 25-30, and the CC was at 0.5 or lower. The pool looks better than at anytime in the past two years, thanks. Just as the chlorine levels were testing the same in the morning/evening, I ran out of R-0871. I ordered more from SPS, but after two weeks of waiting I finally called them only to be informed my order was still being processed. Needless to say I wasn't pleased with that response. While their prices are good and their site is user friendly, I'm disappointed in their service. In moving on, and assuming it will be another week or two before receipt, I see no other option but to keep adding reduced amounts of bleach for the time being, unless there is another method of testing FC and CC. I do have a couple of test kits on hand that came with the pool, but the CL level only goes to 5.

I ran other tests this morning as follows:

PH - 7.4
TA - 140
CH - 330
CYA - 150

We still have a few weeks left to swim as the temps are remain in the 90s. Since the pool is now clear, I guess my first concern is how to address/lower the CYA. Should I place pucks back in my chlorinator at some point?

Also, once I have the ability to test the FC & CC again, as recommended previously, I will maintain the chlorine in the 10-12 range for the remainder of the swim season and drop it to around 5 or 6 for this off season. Is this correct?

I might add that although we are on water restrictions, we had significant rain last week at which time I had to drain 7-8 inches of water.

Thanks again,
Jim

Hi!!

First off, I'm sorry to hear that you're having problems with SPS--I've ordered from them lots of times and have never had any issues with them. Hopefully they can get your problem resolved and some reagents to you quick.

Here's a link for how to force your test kit to measure higher chlorine levels through dilution: http://www.poolforum.com/pf2/showthread.php?t=10073
It isn't strictly accurate, but it will give you a pretty good ballpark range, and it's much better than guessing. You're right to maintain your chlorine in the 10-12 rainge, but it's not just for the rest of the swim season--you're going to have to maintain it that high until you drop your CYA levels if you want to stay algae-free. Unfortunately, there are only two ways I know to drop the CYA--one is drain and refill water, and the other is to let the pool go into a green swampy mess during the winter, and the bacteria will dissolve the CYA into byproducts such as ammonia, that take HUGE amounts of chlorine to overcome once you open the pool again. (I obviously don't recommend that route! ).

Since you are in south Texas, I'm assuming that you won't close your pool this winter? If not, if you were to frequently backwash and refill gradually over the wintertime, coupled with rainwater, etc, you might be able to lower the CYA gradually enough so that it would be more manageable by next winter. You absolutely do NOT want to add pucks back to the chlorinator, because they drive your CYA upward, and yours is on the verge of being so high that even elevated chlorine levels can't compensate. You'll do better to stick with plain, unscented bleach or liquid chlorine for your chlorine source. Or--for more effortless maintenance, you might want to consider adding a salt water chlorine generator!!

Janet

I still can't get my CYA right; remains around 150; guess I will have to drain some of the water. When my pool was installed, the contractor informed me that fiberglass pools could not be completely drained. If true, what percentage can I safely drain?

Thanks in advance.

Jim

I don't know how I missed this post-- I'm sorry!! This should bump it to the top, though. If your CYA is really 150, the only way your pool is going to be manageable is to drain/refill water. I definitely would not drain it att at one time because if your water table is high, it can "float" the pool. Rather, if possible, I would do two 50% drains, which should drop it down to a much more manageable level.

Janet

Finally, getting ready to drain the my pool to stabalize the CYA and have decided to buy a submersible sump pump rather than rent one. Would appreciate it if anyone has a recommendation for a decent pump, keeping in mind that I will likely only use it a few times. Talked with a couple of folks that purchased from hardware stores; both stated the pumps were just okay at best.

Thanks,

Jim

No advice on the pump, but just wanted to caution you that when you start draining, don't let the shallow end drain all the way, make sure that you still have at least 3-4 feet of water in the shallow when you stop draining. You might call one of your local guys that install liners to ask about the water tables in your specific part of the country.

Janet