Above ground salt chlorine generator

Looking for advice on what salt chlorine generator to get for an above ground pool. It is a new pool, about 17,000 gallons. I already have the salt in the pool, and had an inline salt chlorine generator that was defective (Splash Simpl Chlor Above-Ground Saltwater Chlorine Generator). Of course, I don't want to spend more than I have to. I know some on this forum are against above ground salt water pools, but I would rather not debate that here. Lets just assume that is dead and I am in the market for a chlorine generator for an above ground pool.
Thanks

I guess maybe some are against SWCG's for AG pools, but I'm not, and I don't think the mods are. We do try to inform people of risks, just like I do every time I tell people to use muriatic acid.

Bottom line: any SWCG with sufficient capacity for your pool's volume and bather load is fine. There's nothing intrinsic to a salt generator that says this one must be for AG pools and that one for IG pools. In fact, a SWCG for an 17,000 gallon AG pool probably ought be a bit higher in capacity than for an IG pool, because AG pools tend to get used more, where IG pools are often more ornamental.

My own experience with SWCGs is limited, but I've used Pentair IC units sucessfully. If I were running your pool, and it was heavily used, I'd get an IC-40. If it's only very lightly used, I'd get an IC-20. But that's just because that's what's familiar to me, and has worked for me.

Ben

Welcome to the Forum!

I'll toss in the Aqua-Trol (Hayward/ Goldline) as a decent AG pool SWCG, though at 17000 gal you might want to upgrade to the T-20 cell.