Time to replace hayward super pump 1.5 hp what should I get?

[cj93z]

I have a 20000 gallon IG pool with an old anthony apollo DE grid filter that is about 50 sqf. I have one skimmer and one return and the equipment is about 15 feet from the pool. My 1.5 uprated super pump has died and I need to replace it. I'd like to get something more efficient and not overpower my filter. I was thinking a 1hp northstar but I'm not sure....

[anotherpyr]

One thing to consider is the dimensions of the two pumps. The Northstar has a higher inlet port and the outlet port is set back farther. It also as 2" ports instead of 1 1/2".

There are also two 1 hp versions of the Northstar. An max rated one which is really the 3/4 hp one, and a full rated 1 hp. The flow rates are different. From the performance data listed at the Hayward website for the 2 pumps, the full rated 3/4 hp or max rated 1 hp Northstar come closest to the 1 1/2 hp Super Pump in performance and still has a bit more flow.

Of course this is assuming that the current pump is the correct size. See http://poolplaza.com/pool-pump-sizing-2.shtml for an idea of what is involved in determining the pump size. There is a posting in the forum here somewhere that has some good info on pump sizing and another link to a page for figuring out pump size.

As an example I have a 2 speed 1 hp Super Pump on a 20,000 gallon ig pool with the pump and filter 15' from the pool edge. I get enough flow on high to over power a Polaris 360 and I have 2 skimmers and returns. So feet of head is everything.

[CarlD]

I have the same pump (1HP 2spd Superpump), about 15' of head, 20,000k, and run solar panels about 3' above the pump--technically it's an AG pool, but functionally, being rectangular, big, with a deep end, it's more like and IG.
I have the 200# top mount Hayward sand filter.