New pool owner, BBB Opening, cloudy water.

[JesseWV]

I am a new pool owner. The previous owner left me with a tablet floater and a 3-way Chlorine/Bromine & pH tester. I had to make a few repairs because while moving the filter for the winter one of the fittings from the skimmer line shattered and the pressure gauge also broke right off with very little force.

After completing repairs I took off the cover. I was surprised to see that the water was very clear. There was a brown film on the bottom and a small pile of debris in the middle.

I tested the water with the 3-way kit. The levels indicated where practically non-existent. The chlorine test was clear the pH test was almost clear. In an attempt to raise the pH to 7.5 I picked up a jug of "Aquachem pH Up" (Sodium Carbonate) (I know, I know, I hadn't seen the light yet.) The directions instructed me to ad 30oz for a 15,000 gallon pool with a pH of 6.5 or below. I added the product to the surface of the pool above the circulation jet which seemed to stir it up quite well. It dissolved quickly. I waited 1 hour and then tested the pH again. The result was the same. Frustrated I then added the remainder of the jug which was 34oz. I tested again in 1 hour but the result was still the same. I was wondering if the test kit was bad so I dissolved a few granules of the pH up that were left in the jug into a measuring cup of water and tested it. The color was now light pink.

I knew something wasn't right so I decided to do some research online and came upon this forum. I found that using a 3-way test kit would not give me all the information about the water that I needed. I bought a bottle of 6-way test strips. I tested the water and the results were all extremely low.

After browsing the forums I found the BBB thread and knew that this was something worth looking into as I hate paying inflated prices for name brand anything. I was a little concerned about the borate levels in the water since I have pets and young children so I decided to keep them around 25ppm.

Now that I had a plan I filled the pool up to the middle of the skimmer with city water then vacuumed the brown film and debris from the bottom and vacuumed the sides for good measure. The water got much more cloudy from the debris being kicked up from cleaning.

I went to Walmart and picked up:

(3) 76oz boxes of 20 Mule Team Borax (Sodium Tetraborate)
(3) 64oz boxes & (1) 192oz Bag of Arm & Hammer Baking Soda (Sodium Bicarbonate)
(1) 55oz box of Arm & Hammer Washing Soda (Sodium Carbonate)
(6) 1lb socks of Aquachem Shock Plus (Sodium Dichloro-s-triazinetrione)
(3) 182oz Jug 6% Bleach (Sodium Hyprochlorite)

I added all of the Borax and tested about 1 hour later. The pH and TA went up a little. I then added all of the Baking Soda, tested 1 hour later. The TA was almost perfect the pH was a little low. I added the Washing Soda and tested about an hour later. The pH level was now very good.

Satisfied with the water balance I decided to shock the water. I added 1 and a half socks of Shock Plus. I decided to use the dichlor product for initial shocking and chlorination because there was no CYA present to begin with. I waited about 45 min and then tested. The TC was around 1ppm, FC around 2ppm, and CYA less than 30ppm. I added the remaining 0.5lb sock and another 1lb sock, waited 30 min and tested. The levels were now TC: 3ppm, FC 4ppm, and CYA around 40ppm.

It was now dark and I needed the water fully shocked so I added one more sock of Dichlor and let the pump run all night. I woke up this morning to see the debris in the water cleared up quite well but there is still a cloudiness to the water.

Problem: Cloudy Water

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/_AIvhc-r8ZEA/TbbldvOawbI/AAAAAAAAAuM/Ij4dlI69N6E/s640/PICT0515.JPG


FC: 2
TC: 10
pH: 7.4
TA: 120
CH: 100
CYA: 50

Just in case I'm reading it wrong, here is a photo of the test results.
https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/_AIvhc-r8ZEA/TbbiOCrzK9I/AAAAAAAAAtw/cbOPRaqw1GA/s800/PICT0508.JPG
Test pad order: Total Hardness, TC, FC/BR, pH, TA, CYA.

My pool: 27.5ft round x 3.5-4ft depth

Pool chemicals: Dichlor for inital CYA loading, Bleach thereafter.

My pump & filter: AO Smith 1HP BN25 Pump, Hayward S160T Filter

[AnnaK]

Hi Jesse,

Welcome to PF! It sounds like you've already done a lot of research and reading and are well on your way to a 5-minutes-a-day swim season.

I would do two things:
1. Get a FAS-DPD test kit like the Taylor K2006 (.75 oz reagent bottles) or the K2006C (2 oz. reagents). Water testing is far more accurate with these kits than with test strips.
2. Keep the pump/filter running 24/7. If you have a 2-speed pump you can run it on 'low'. Put it through a backwash/rinse cycle if the pressure rises to 5 PSI above normal 'clean' pressure.

If you have visible collections of debris on the bottom, vacuum. In my area I'm getting a lot of tree bracts from the birches right now. Soggy pollen which sinks to the bottom can look like dust as well.

Do you have a Leslie's pool store in the vicinity? They do their water tests with the Taylor kits and I've found their results reasonably reliable with regard to pH, FC, and TC. Having the water tested at a pool store using manual techniques rather than a colorimeter would give us a better starting point with regard to current balance. I'm really hesitant to give any chemical advice based on the test strip results—can you tell? :)

[Watermom]

You can order the Taylor K-2006 or 2006C from the link in my signature below. By ordering it through this link, the Pool Forum makes a little bit of money from the sale which helps us stay up and running! Welcome to the forum!

[chem geek]

For coordination sake, note that this user is also posting also at Swimming Pool Help Forums (http://x.havuz.org/viewtopic.php?p=29276#p29276) and at Trouble Free Pool (http://www.troublefreepool.com/first-time-pool-owner-bbb-method-opening-cloudy-water-t30492.html).

[Watermom]

Thanks, Richard for that tidbit.

Jesse -- We are glad to have you here on the Pool Forum, but it is going to be difficult for us to help you if you are following advice from multiple sources. When we are helping somebody with a problem, the only way we can do a good job helping them is if we know everything going on with that pool. If you are taking bits and pieces of advice from various sources, not only does it make it harder for anyone to be able to help but it also may make it harder for you to clear up any problems you may be having. It is probably best if you post a problem on one forum and let your advice all be coming from the same place. Hope that makes sense!:)

[CarlD]

Jesse,
If you are going to use strips, at least you got the right ones, from Hach. They are really only good as a stop-gap but you can use them. Ignore TC--it's never even close to right. FC, for now, should always be purple, even more intensely than the "10".
TA is hard to read but generally is sorta OK. I find CYA almost impossible to read, but, the key is "almost". For pH you are better off with a decent OTO/pH test kit than the strips. Try to get one with chlorine neutralizer (Taylor's version is # 0014, rather than 0004).

I suspect the advice from TFP should be very similar to ours, as it's based on B-B-B as well, but I don't follow them, and I know NOTHING about Swimming Pool Help Forums--never heard of them. Given that, you should either rely on us for advice or on TFP. It SHOULD be about the same, but may not be, so if it deviates, go one way or the other and stick to it.

CarlD